Keto vs Calorie Deficit: Which Diet Is Better?

4/26/2023

When it comes to losing weight, two popular approaches are the ketogenic diet and the calorie deficit diet. The ketogenic diet, commonly called the keto diet, involves restricting carbohydrates to induce ketosis, where the body starts to burn fat for energy. On the other hand, the calorie deficit diet involves consuming fewer calories than the body requires, leading to a calorie deficit and weight loss. So, which is better - the keto or calorie deficit diet?

Both diets have their proponents. However, the keto diet makes it easier for you to eat less calories per day, as it decreases your apetite. In contrast, the calorie deficit diet is more likely to make you feel hungry all the time. So, in the keto vs. calorie deficit dilemma, it's 1-0 for the keto diet.

Keep reading, as this article will dive into the keto vs. calorie deficit debate in more detail and explain the differences between the two diets. We'll help you determine the best approach for your goals and lifestyle.

Key Takeaways

The keto diet induces ketosis and burns fat for energy because the diet restricts carbohydrates.
The calorie deficit diet, also known as calorie counting, involves tracking the number of calories consumed to create a calorie deficit.
The choice between the two approaches to weight loss depends on individual preferences and lifestyle factors.

Keto Diet Overview

The keto diet is a dietary plan that emphasizes high-fat, adequate protein, and low-carbohydrate foods. It supplies the body with more calories from fat than from carbohydrates. When the body's sugar reserves are reduced, the diet induces ketosis, breaking down fat for energy and producing molecules called ketones. People on the keto diet consume foods that fill them up easily and reduce hunger-stimulating hormones.

Research has shown that the keto diet promotes weight loss by lowering appetite and boosting metabolism. It also reduces acne symptoms and lowers the risk of certain cancers. According to Penn Medicine, keto diet improves heart health by reducing cholesterol levels and protecting brain function. Moreover, it may reduce seizures and alleviate polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) symptoms.

Keto Diet Foods to Eat

Some keto diet foods you can eat and include:

Meat and poultry
Fish and seafood
Low-carb vegetables like spinach and kales
Dairy products such as cream
Nuts and seeds, including almonds, macadamia nuts, and chia seeds
Avocado and coconut products
Berries such as strawberries, raspberries, and blackberries
Health oils including olive oil and coconut oil

Opt for thoughtfully prepared ketogenic dishes by award winning chefs, delivered conveniently to your doorstep! Enjoy Cook Unity’s keto meal delivery service anytime, and save time and hassle! Achieve your weight loss goals the easy way with Cookunity's Low-Calorie meal delivery service today!

Keto Diet Foods to Avoid

Avoid the following foods when on a keto diet:

Grains: wheat, rice, and corn
Sugars: honey, maple syrup, and agave nectar
High-carb fruits: bananas, apples, and oranges
Processed foods and snacks, including chips and crackers
Legumes: beans and lentils
Starchy vegetables: potatoes and corn

Calorie Deficit Diet Overview

A calorie deficit diet is a weight loss strategy that reduces calorie intake below the body's energy expenditure. Calories measure energy derived from either food or drinks.

Generally, a daily 500 calorie deficit is sufficient for weight loss without causing extreme hunger or fatigue. You can use online calculators to determine your maintenance calories or track your calorie intake and weight for ten days. You must reduce your calorie intake and increase your physical activity levels to create a calorie deficit.

It’s easier to achieve a significant calorie deficit through diet control rather than exercise alone—but you shouldn’t underestimate the power of muscle-strengthening and aerobic exercises. Physical activities that help in stretching muscles guide the body in prioritizing the loss of body fat instead of muscle mass. Unfortunately, there are some potential challenges to achieving a calorie deficit which include hunger, cravings, and reduced energy levels.

Calorie Deficit Diet Foods to Eat

You can eat the following low-calorie foods when on a calorie deficient diet:

Lean proteins like fish, chicken, and turkey
Whole grains
Whole wheat bread
Vegetables, especially leafy greens like spinach and kale
Fruits, particularly those with low sugar content, such as berries and citrus fruits
Healthy fats like avocado and nuts
Low-fat dairy products, such as Greek yogurt
Beans and legumes high in protein and fiber

Calorie Deficit Diet Foods to Avoid

Below are foods you need to avoid while on a calorie deficient diet:

Processed foods and snacks tend to be high in calories and low in nutrients.
Sugary drinks like soda
Foods rich in saturated and trans fats, such as fried foods and fatty meats
High-calorie desserts, including cakes, cookies, and ice cream
Alcohol, which is high in calories and low in nutrients
High-carb foods, such as white bread, pasta, and rice
Foods are high in sodium, such as canned soups and packaged snacks

Comparison of Keto Diet vs. Calorie Deficit Diet

Nutritional Differences

A calorie deficit diet is one where you consume fewer calories than your body requires, creating a negative energy balance. On the other hand, the ketogenic diet is high in fat, low in carbohydrates, and moderate in protein. This decreases insulin and supresses your apetite. The keto diet also often helps you lose weight rather fast in the first few weeks.

Potential Health Benefits and Risks

Calorie deficit and keto diets can lead to short-term weight loss. However, in the long term, the calorie deficit approach is more suitable for individuals who prefer more food varieties. The keto diet can be limiting and expensive, mainly meat and dairy.

Studies show that a ketogenic diet reduces hunger levels and food intake in the short term. It can also help with Type 2 diabetes, Alzheimer's disease, and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. However, it can negatively affect plasma lipid concentrations. Additionally, carbohydrate restriction can cause a lack of phytochemicals, and other elements found in fruits, vegetables, and whole grains.

Potential Challenges and Benefits of Each Diet

The calorie deficit diet offers more food choices, making it more realistic to continue calorie restriction in the long term. It also has fewer dietary restrictions than the keto diet, making adherence easier. The keto diet, on the other hand, can lead to reduced postprandial glycemia, increased ketone body production, and improved energy expenditure.

Keto vs. Calorie Deficit - Which Diet Is Better?

Overall, the calorie deficit diet is better than the keto diet for weight loss because it allows for more food choices. Therefore, calorie deficit can be achieved in any food group, whether you consume carbs or not.

Obtaining a calorie deficit with a ketogenic diet is more beneficial, especially for weight loss goals. Additionally, the ketogenic diet also helps with Type 2 diabetes, and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Nevertheless, the keto diet is more restrictive and can lead to vitamin and mineral deficiencies.

Keto vs Calorie Deficit: FAQs

Q: Keto vs 1,200 Calorie Diet – Which One Is Better for Weight Loss?

A: Both approaches can be effective for weight loss, but the 1,200-calorie diet allows for more variety in food choices, while the keto diet is limited to mainly meat and dairy.

Q: Which Is Better - Calorie Deficit or Intermittent Fasting?

A: Calorie deficit works by reducing the number of calories you consume, while intermittent fasting restricts the period in which you can eat. Some people find intermittent fasting easier, while others prefer calorie restriction. Ultimately, the best approach should be sustainable and you should be able to maintain it in the long term.

Q: Does Calorie Deficit Cause Ketosis?

A: Calorie deficit doesn’t cause ketosis. Ketosis is when the body uses ketones from the breakdown of fats in the liver as the main energy source instead of glucose. Typically, ketosis is associated with a low-carb, high-fat diet like keto.

Q: Does Keto Work Better Than Calorie Deficit?

A: While ketogenic diets lower appetite and even help in burning more calories, they don't perform better than other diets in the long term. In the short term, keto dieters lose more weight, but keto diets may be more satiating than others.

Conclusion

There is a significant confusion when it comes to losing weight with low-carb diets and calorie restrictions. The choice between the two diets depends on individual preferences, lifestyle, and health status. The calorie deficit diet is more flexible and provides more options, while the keto diet can benefit some health conditions. Consult healthcare experts before making any dietary changes.

Making informed dietary choices is important because a healthy diet can help prevent chronic diseases such as obesity, diabetes, and heart disease. One must consider personal preferences, lifestyle, and overall health goals when choosing between calorie deficit and the keto diet. Finally, there is no specific approach to weight loss. Exploring different options and finding the one that works best for your lifestyle and personal preferences is essential. Some people succeed with calorie restriction, while others prefer a low-carb diet like keto.

References:

Meet Our Chefs

We are a community of more than 70 chefs from across the country — bringing you a gourmet at-home dining experience you can’t find anywhere else.